1. What is Serra’s legacy today?

As the Father of California, Serra today represents multicultural appreciation and tolerance. Serra worked tirelessly for — and treasured — the Native Americans as human beings and treated them with dignity and respect. Today he is a model of evangelization, a man who truly went to the peripheries of civilization and sacrificed everything to minister to those who had yet to hear the Gospel. His impact on California continues to be felt in ways large and small throughout the state.

2. What is canonization?

Canonization is an affirmation on the part of the Catholic Church that an individual is in heaven. It does not mean that this individual was a perfect human being, but rather that they exemplified heroic goodness and virtue during their life.

3. Why is Father Serra a saint?

Father Junipero Serra left behind a life of academic prestige and renown to take on a life of hardship, sacrifice and toil in order to become an advocate and spiritual minister to the Native California Indians. Defying many obstacles, including, at times, members of the civil government, Serra devoted himself to attracting hearts to Christ. He exemplified heroic virtues in the California frontier, and through his grace and perseverance he brought the Gospel of Christ to many who had not heard it before.

4. Was Serra a colonist whose culture conquered the Native Californians?

Serra was a citizen of an empire, but his mission was one of evangelization, not of politics. Serra’s driving motivation was to win the natives’ hearts for Christ. When he saw injustice and abuse in the Spanish political system, he advocated for the natives’ rights and dignity. Serra was more than a man of his times; he was ahead of his times, and he is being canonized for his heroic virtues.

5. Would the Indians have been better without Spain?

The European colonization of North America was inevitable, and given the disparity in technology between Europeans and Native Americans, it was almost completely assured of success. If Spain had not colonized California, Russia would have done so from the Pacific Northwest, or Britain would have done so from the east. In areas where both of these countries colonized, Native American populations were almost entirely wiped out. Though American history is usually seen through a more British lens, the fact is that Natives Americans generally fared better under Spanish rule than under the British and enjoyed certain protections, some of which Father Serra went to great lengths to secure for them. As Gregory Orfalea states, “After two hundred years of conquest in Spanish America, half the population was still Indian, whereas east of the Mississippi in English America, only 6 percent remained Indian.”

6. What about whipping as a form of punishment in the missions?

There is no documented evidence that Serra himself employed corporal punishment on the Native Californians. What we do know, however, is that corporal punishment was a widely accepted form of punishment in both the Old World and the New World in Serra’s time. Militaries throughout Europe, including the Spanish military, widely employed flogging on their own sailors until 1824, and the U.S. military did so until 1861 — a century after Serra’s arrival in the New World. Monastic orders such as the Benedictines also prescribed corporal punishment as a form of moral chastisement. Additionally, the Aztecs, who were among the first Native Americans whom Serra encountered, employed such disciplines on children as beating and breathing in the fumes from smoking chilies.

7. Were the Natives forced to convert to Catholicism and be the padres’ slaves?

Forced conversions were forbidden in the Catholic Church as they are today. Native Californians were not permitted to enter the missions unless they had chosen freely to do so and had undergone a lengthy process of catechesis. They were also not admitted unless the padres could guarantee that the missions had enough food and resources to provide for the needs of each Native Californian. Once they entered the missions, the natives had daily responsibilities for maintaining the missions, working side by side with the friars.

8. The Native Californian population declined after contact with Europeans. Is Serra responsible?

Ironically, the greatest decimation of the Native American population in California occurred after the missions were secularized and California was ceded to the United States. At that point, the population of the Native Californians fell by about 80 percent. During the mission era, most Native Californians who died prematurely did so because of European diseases to which the Indians had no immunity. It is clear that the native population suffered losses, but it was not because of Father Serra, who, if anything, probably ameliorated their situation. Rather, it was the spread of diseases which neither the Spaniards nor the Indians of the 18th century had the technology to address. There was a population decline among the Native Californians as a result of this disease during the mission period, but it was a fraction of the complete collapse of the population that followed Americanization.

9. Would the Indians have been better without Serra?

In a word, no. Many scholars of the period agree that, on balance, without Father Serra’s presence and advocacy, things could have been much more difficult for the Indians. Serra devoted his life to the hearts and souls of the Native Californians, fighting abuses against them. Among his many efforts to defend the rights and dignity of the Native Californians, Serra secured rights intended to prevent the Spanish soldiers from abusing and exploiting the Natives; he refused to permit the Spanish government to tax the Indians; and he succeeded in having the Spanish General Fages fired for his treatment of the natives and for allowing the rape of native women.

10. What motivated Serra to become a missionary in the New World?

Serra’s deepest motivations were love of God and love of neighbor. As a young seminarian, Serra read the works of the great medieval missionary and evangelist Raymond Lull and internalized deeply Christ’s call to “go forth and preach to all nations.” Although he held an endowed chair as a professor of theology and philosophy in Mallorca (Majorca), his heart yearned to share the Gospel of Jesus Christ with the native people of the New World who had not yet heard the Good News. A desire to win hearts for Christ caused him to give up his academic position, leave his family, cross a vast ocean, and devote the rest of his life to serving and ministering to the native people of California.

11. How did the Indians interact with him at the time?

Serra’s deep compassion and grace was evident to the native Indians of Alta California. He was deeply affected by the natives’ generosity and gentleness toward him. Serra wrote several times of one incident where several members of the Chumash Tribe met him as he was walking through a mountain pass shortly after a rain storm. Since the ground was muddy and Serra’s leg was wounded, two Chumash Indians held him on either side and carried him over the mountain pass. Serra wrote afterwards in several letters that he would never be able to repay the kindness that they had shown to him.

12. What did Indians say about him after his death?

Serra’s biographer, who was present in his last days on earth, wrote that as Serra lay dying, the mission Indians wept outside his room. At his funeral, the friars eventually had to intervene because the Indians cut off pieces of Serra’s hair and vestments to treasure as relics. To the Indians, Serra was a spiritual father and a protector, and they deeply mourned his death.

Maynard Geiger conducted a series of oral interviews with the descendants of mission Indians who had known Serra. Even for several generations after Serra’s death, the Indians referred to him as “el santo”— the saint.